The lighting is so often an afterthought – a few lampshades thrown in when the rest of the work is finished and the money has run out. But it is such a key part of a design scheme – so easy to get wrong and so stunning when it’s done right, that I collaborated with John Cullen Lighting to create a mini series showing you the dos and don’ts room by room.
Sally Storey, the design director of John Cullen Lighting, who has written several books on the subject, visited my house and we went round each room in the house talking about what I had done right (not so much) what I had done wrong (rather more) and how I could put things right or improve them. Along the way we discussed different products and lighting effects and basically tried to demistify the subject so that it would be useful for everyone.
We started off in my kitchen, where I had at least followed one of Sally’s rules: you don’t need to put your downlights/spotlights – call them what you will – in a grid pattern across the ceiling. You need to decide where you actually need them and place them accordingly, which I have managed to do over the island. The point being that if they are properly installed you should barely see the lights themselves but merely the light that they provide – if you see what I mean.
And this is the first place I went wrong. Most of us don’t buy properly recessed downlights. This we end up with the bulb flush with the ceiling which means you see both the bulb and a harsh light around it rather than just being aware of light in the place that you need it to be. So that’s the second tip: if you are having downlighters then make sure you buy ones with a bulb that is concealed from view. Ideally the bulb should have a black baffle, which is a tube that sets the light source back away from the ceiling. It might sound counter-intuitive in a white ceiling but trust me on this (well at least trust Sally) it will make it more invisible. A white surrounding will reflect the light from the bulb back out making you more aware of it. A black surround will absorb the immediate harshness of the bulb light and refract back only the soft light that you need to see by.
So we’ve established that you don’t need your lights in a uniform grid, you need to hide them up in the ceiling and the bulb needs a black baffle (try the Polespring from John Cullen). Finally, they should be over the middle of the worktop so you can see what you are doing but don’t create your own shadow. And here too I went wrong. I appear to have lighted a runway down the middle of the kitchen rather than lighting the shelves or artwork. Now that Sally has pointed that out it seems so blindingly obvious (and stupid) that I can’t quite believe I did it.
The next issue is one of atmosphere. It can be hard to create this in kitchens when most of us just use those downlights. Rule number 1: dimmers. Sally uses them in every room. She also divides lights into different circuits so you can choose which parts of the room to light at any given time.
I scored one point by pointing to a table lamp that I have in one corner. I was quietly congratulating myself when Sally said I needed another at the other end. And that I should have a wall light at one end of the work top. Desperate to claw back some credibility, I said I had been thinking about that but wasn’t sure if one wall light on its own would work when I couldn’t have one at the other end. She sniffed at my desire for symmetry and suggested an industrial style light at one end as she has in her kitchen. I immediately want that.
Sally is also a fan of using lights in clever ways. She is a big fan of LED tape which she suggested I could fix under my open shelves and which would throw soft light out and highlight the items displayed on them. I’m not one for lighting the base of the island which feels a bit space age for my kitchen but I can see how it might work in a more modern setting.
Finally, the dining end. Clearly we lost major points here because we don’t have a dimmer switch but Sally had a few other suggestions. In her kitchen she has put spotlights in the floor next to the wall. When turned on these throw a soft wash of light up over the walls which looks like gentle lamplight from a hidden source.
My ceiling isn’t high enough for pendant lights although Sally said she would have hidden a spotlight deep in the ceiling which would, like the others, be invisible but just send a shaft of light down to illuminate the table.
I have a skylight in my kitchen which isn’t lit at all. One of the common problems is that at night the bulbs are reflected back up against the glass creating harsh light. Sally suggests hollowing out a groove and installing more LED tape so the dots of the bulbs are hidden but the ambient light remains.
What I found really interesting as we walked round my kitchen was that having tried to think of an alternative to spot lights and completely failed, I actually think I could have lit the whole room without using any. Thus: wall light at the end of the worktop and table lamps at either end of the cupboards, LED tape on the open shelves, floorlights in the dining end and a couple of dimmable wall lights by the table.
Finally, Sally said not to neglect the outside. Even in winter I could have a couple of lights on in the garden or on the deck which would throw a soft light back into the dining end of the room as well as softly illuminating the world outside – rather than just a deep black nothing on the other side of the glass.
In short the rules for the kitchen:
Do not put your spotlights in a symmetrical grid
Make sure your spotlights are recessed into the ceiling
Always install dimmer switches
Have the lights on two or three different circuits so you can choose which part of the room to light
Consider wall, table and pendant lights in every room – including the kitchen
Think about imaginative use of LED tape
Don’t forget the outside
John Cullen hold lighting workshops if you’re interested in learning more detail than I can provide here, check the website for details.
[…] Finding the right kitchen lighting. […]
This is an excellent and highly informative post and a great read for someone new (ish) to Kate’s blog. The big issue here for me and possibly other readers is that our kitchens are already designed/decorated and it is not feasible to take them back to the bare walls and floor until a major refit is due.
It would be really useful to have a similar post in the future on how to do a retrospective lighting design. Even simple things like LED strips can be messy if there are no suitable wall sockets nearby.
That’s a really good point, Gary and I shall look into it. I think there will always have to be a certain amount of mess with lighting as you have to fit the cables into the walls if you are moving it around, but I will investigate the subject.
I will never forget my excitement at reading this posting/info. At the time I was doing our kitchen extension and about to plan for a runway of lights! I followed it religiously and even the lighting shop were impressed with the lighting plan. One note – good lighting is not cheap but the results are well worth the money.
I agree completely! My favorite place to buy wallpaper, home accessories and lighting is http://www.your4walls.co.uk. Thanks for the great blog
Great post, well illustrated to explain the points.
I have halogen spots in the kitchen. Are they lined up? To the extent that they are over the counters, yes. They are well-recessed and not very noticeable, but very practical–they give great light, just where it’s needed. Halogens seem to give off a very directed light–it doesn’t go all over the place. So the room can seem dark, with very bright light only under the spot.
We installed them before LEDs were an option, so maybe we would do it differently now.
[…] to the fourth and final part* of my series on How To Get the Lighting Right in partnership withJohn Cullen. I do hope you have enjoyed it and found it useful. For new […]
[…] to the fourth and final part* of my series on How To Get the Lighting Right in partnership with John Cullen. I do hope you have enjoyed it and found it useful. For new […]
[…] The following is excerpted from a recent post by Kate Watson-Smyth of Mad About the House. […]
I really enjoyed reading this, great blog and some really great tips! Love the pics!
Great post! It`s a pity I already have only spot light installed in my kitchen. Hope I will improve it with some addings
Great article. One of the best things we did when we did our extension was to get a (affordable) lighting plan for the new space. Sooooo many people have commented on it and in fact my builder called me back after he had moved on to get the designers details after telling me 100 times that I didn’t have enough lights. Can’t wait for the next one as now it’s all up to me but I learnt a lot so fingers crossed I can get it right.
Brilliant article. Often an overlooked issue but some brilliant tips. We are moving into a 1950s ‘dooer upper’ next week, it’s a complete renovation job with only one (dodgy) plug point in each room. So 2 weeks before Christmas with 2 small children…..I need all the help I can get!
So thank you!
Oh this is just fab. I have been wrestling with the lighting plan for my new kitchen/dining space for a few weeks now and felt very pleased with myself after a trip to the local electrical shop too. I award myself 5/10 – so many things missing/wrong e.g. the spots in a line or grid, the LED strip under shelves, ugly bulk head lights in the garden. Time to happily go back to the drawing board. Thanks for a fab posting today and looking forward to next month’s instalment.
Excellent Kate- really useful!
Love this post – great lighting makes sooooo much difference. Going to start work on my kitchen lighting scheme right away!! Looking forward to next months lighting post already!